A Critical Review of Stephanie J.
Coopman and James Lull, 2011, decision making in United State: Public Speaking
the Evolving Art, Published
by Belmont, California, U.S.A.: Wadsworth Pub Co, 2010, ISBN 10: 0495798525 / ISBN 13: 9780495798521.
Public Speaking the Evolving Art is the
book that integrated technology package to meet the expectations of today's
students while both preserving and offering innovative variations on the
well-respected traditions of public speaking instruction. This book also explained
about how to speak well in public speaking. The author, Stephanie J. Coopman is a Doctor of
Philosophy in University Of Kentucky in 1989. And then, she is also the Master
of Arts, Speech Communication and Dramatic Arts Central Michigan University, in
1982. And also she is a Bachelor of Science, Communication Arts and Sciences
Western Michigan University, in 1979. After that, about the second author is
James Lull. He is a Professor Emeritus of Communication
Studies at San José State University.
This research aimed to give the best
ways for the student to speak well in public speaking class. And then, also
explain about how to prepare to speak and give guidelines for effective
communication to speak. Stephanie
J. Coopman and James Lull (2011), taking an applied
approach, Public Speaking: the Evolving Art, Second
Edition, and its unique suite of companion
resources address the ways in which digital technology,
social transitions, and cultural shifts have affected
students and the communication discipline. This text
offers a unique combination of time-honored, classic public
speaking instruction and specific guidelines for effective
public communication in today’s evolving world (p. 16). However, not all the way to the students managed to put into practice, because
most of the students were afraid to speak in public or in front of the classroom. Therefore,
it still needed the
best way and also requires
a short time to practice
it. The Princeton Language Institute and Lenny
Laskowski (2001), some
people are self-conscious about their appearance or voice. Others are afraid
they will be laughed at or criticized. Such fears can compromise your
effectiveness, preventing you from becoming a more confident public speaker (p.
12). The research proves public speaking is
not as easy as imagined. As
stated by Lenny Laskowski on her book
"10 Days to
More Confident Public
Speaking", that there are
several ways or
methods to speak better in public or in front of the class.
If self-confidence has
been obtained, it will be easier
to convey information
or material to be
conveyed by the students in the classroom. Arina Nikitina’s book “Successful Public Speaking” said that “Improving
your ability to speak in front of many people talk about who you are and what
you do with naturally, can build strong relationship with successful,
like-minded people and making new friends” (chapter. 1). This means that, self-confidence
is one of the important things in appearance while public
speaking. It is also related to the arrangement will be made when speaking. In the book "A Pocket Guide to Public Speaking" by Dan O'Hair, Hannah Rubenstein and
Rob Stewart said
that there are several
ways and patterns
in public speaking that also related with the
base context in learning speaking. This book
discusses the steps and how to speak
well in public speaking class. I think that
this book is intended for students in college
and high school. This
is one of a good example to practiced
because, in this book contains elements that are commonly done by previous
students, such as the use of media tools.
Therefore, it would be better if this
method be applied. However, before that, it
is worth doing slowly this
method to students
in high school because
they have not been as sharp understanding comprehension
that can be done by
students in college.
In
summary, I as a reviewer, choose the best chapter of the Public Speaking the Evolving Art from unit III until unit IV that
can more explain about way to success in public speaking. This
book discusses not
only how to speak
well, but also gives
the composition of the steps to start speaking.
The ways such; determining the purpose and topic, adapting
to audience, researching the topic, organizing the ideas, practicing the speech
and presenting the speech, it’s the entire general step what the student have
to do to speaking. However, for this unit just explain about “Presenting Yourself and Your Ideas
and Speaking Situation”. So, as recent graduate student and new teacher, I
found the author’s descriptions of the way or step to speaking is true, because
when I learn in the speaking class, I get
a lesson that how
to speaking a good way to use all the materials that
have been taught as one of them is to train the confidence.
created by : Ghea Ameliona (Gee)
created by : Ghea Ameliona (Gee)
Komentar ini telah dihapus oleh pengarang.
BalasHapusAre you talking about what Anisa? there is no comment, and empty post...
BalasHapusokay ghea, we got same topic, the steps show how to speak well in public speaking class. But, most people feel uncomfortable in public speaking class. So, I hope we all (member of K-3 '11) can apply those steps in the classroom.. amin, thank you :)
BalasHapusYeah Rani, Insyaallah we can do it soon :') Thank you so much :*
Hapusyour book review is quiet good..
BalasHapusyou give the abstract information about speaking and how to improve your self- confidence when you speaking in public.
I think this book enable to read by all students such as secondary school and college students..
but, in your review book.. why you don't tell more how to improve that method.. I mean, why you do not tell step by step to make the readers understand easy to understand without looking the real e-book
Thank you for your comment and suggestion, Nadia. Insyaallah for the next, I'll do that.,,
Hapusspaeking,,, hm,,,interesting topic..... i have seen you in delivering your review in front of class. good try..... we just need to train our comprehension in accuracy,,, just it,,,,
BalasHapusThank you Intan.. You know, you have a talent to speak in public speaking,, sometimes, I learn the way that you do hehehe
Hapuswe learn together by the proccess cin,,,,,
HapusWhich is exactly what I like ciinnn :'D
Hapusgreat gecong,,,,speaking is interesting topic,,, and I really like with this statement :)
BalasHapus“Improving your ability to speak in front of many people talk about who you are and what you do with naturally, can build strong relationship with successful, like-minded people and making new friends”,,
thankyou for your information,,,
Your welcome Saputang :))
HapusI'm happy too about that,, be better for soon yaa :D
Gechan, I'm sorry about my comment above. :D
BalasHapusIt was a mistake, you can just delete the comment if you want. hehee
well, my comment about your review is: your review is good, I like the way you write it. but, I think it would be better if you give more signal words to indicate that those are your opinions and then you support your opinions with the data you have.
that's all.
thx.
OMG,, I'm sorry about this "missunderstanding" Nichan,, hehe
HapusYeah, I know what you mean,, thank's a lot for all, Insyaallah I'll do that your advice soon,, your welcome :D
It's OK, :)
Hapusyeah, Let's try to be better. :)
Ganbatteeeee :D
Hapus('O')9
okeehh gogob, i like your review..
BalasHapusand i like speak in front of class too. i hope after i read your e-book review i can speak well without nervous and i can speak really fluent in front of class..
but, i little bit confuse about your review when you take opinion of researchers..
thank u :)
Thank you for this comment Peud :D Insyaallah, for the next I'll do the another review better than before, so you can more understand :))
Hapusyour book review is good Ghea. you give some supporting from the another book. However, why you don't give your argument for the another books, too? I think it will make your book review better.
BalasHapusYeah Afi, maybe its one of my mistakes for this task..
HapusThank's for correction,, I just give a related each other for it. Insyallah, for another review, I'll do that your suggestion,, :))
ghea, your book review is very helpful for me to increase my ability in speaking. I am bad on speaking in front of many people.
BalasHapus^_^
you make the information of the book more clearly by adding your opinion.
thank you ghea...
Thank's a lot Ami,, :))
HapusIt's possible for us to do it,, just believe in our self :D
Have a great job for later...
great ghea,,,
BalasHapusi like your book review ...
i hope after i read your e-book review i can speak well without nervous.
Oke Nami, thank you for all :)
HapusActually, if you wanna to practice it, may be you can read my suggestion for cayo,, hihi
Be better soon :D
good job, sista !!! i really appreciated your work and hope it is useful for both of us and may be the other friends...
BalasHapusas our explain before that self-confidence is the key of public speaking, i really agree about it. yet, i still lack in maintaining my self-confidence when i stand in front of people or my audience..can you give me some suggestion to improve it since I know that your good at speaking...thank you :)
Oke Cayosan :D Thank you for all..
Hapusmaybe its just a simple way to speak in front of many people, so perhaps, you have to see "one" direction between the audience. It means that, if you "nervous" to see all of the audience, you can see one of them to reduce your "nervous".. that's it what I do hehe :))
thanks for your information ghea.
BalasHapuswell, I am not good in speaking, but after read your review I think I will be more confident to speak in front of people.
thanks :)
Awesome!!.. Alhmdulillah, thank you for the comment Ices :D Hopefully we can get another information in the another sources to enhancing our skill in speaking...
Hapusghe...
BalasHapusI like your posting
we have same topic !
good job ghee :)
thankss
Right!! because we are the member of the same group right? hihi XP
HapusThank's a lot via,, Be better for the next ya :)
Gea, I wanna ask... If someone has have confident and she/he also can explain the materials very well at public, but if the audience doesn't pay attention to the speakers and the audience can't catch what the speaker said then audience is busy with themselves. have she/he did the public speaking??? What she/he is gonna do???
BalasHapusIf I in this situation, I will try to make something "different".. maybe ask some questions for the audience that didn't want to hear me,, so, maybe she/he shock and after that, she/he aware about what they do...
Hapusthat's it for me iis,,, Thank's for the question... :)
Hi kancut..... Firstly i would like to say i miss u so much
BalasHapusokay, good job ncut.. you essay and the ideas are interesting enough for me, honestly I love it :*
Thank's mbok e,, Why you call me "ncut"? -_- I'm sorry I'm not missing you anymore wkwkwk
Hapusi like your topic ge,, thank u for information. sometimes i face difficult thing in speaking. i am afraid to speak in from public. can you give me some suggestions ge?tq...:)
BalasHapusIt is interesting topic, gea. We have same topic. and from your review, I get more information about how to improve speaking skill.I like your ideas to develop the arguments. thank you gee,,,:)
BalasHapus